It was only a passing thought: Maybe I should write a letter to Frederick Buechner (it’s pronounced BEEKner, by the way) with a CC to Annie Dillard. A couple of things stopped me.
First of all, Fred is in his 80s. I decided anybody who writes the way he does for as long as he has deserved to be spared what would undoubtedly be a sycophantically self-conscious stutterfest on gifts differing as they relate to writing. Besides, I had just finished reading his poems in The Yellow Leaves. The man is certifiably brilliant. Who am I to tell him anything at all about writing? He’d probably fall out of his chair laughing and, God forbid, break a hip.
As for Annie …. Well, that woman just plain scares me to death! Whenever I imagine her, she’s got gunslinger’s eyes. Her writing is somewhere between a stained-glass sunrise and a punch in the gut … either way, it leaves me winded. Then there’s her website. She says, in effect, that she’s very sorry, and yes, she really does care, but she just doesn’t have time to read, let alone answer, all the mail she gets from aspiring authors. Not that I would ever have the nerve to write her, but it’s nice to have an excuse not to.
But the erstwhile letter won’t be denied, so I’m posting it here.
* * *
Dear Fred,
I’m sure you get your share of fan letters, but I figured one more couldn’t hurt, even if you are kind of worn out by opening all the mail. I’ll bet you’ve read the same compliments over and over again, too. I don’t know you, of course, but I picture you bemused by the hubbub. Maybe you just want to be left alone? Well, I don’t mean to bother you, and I may not be saying anything new, but I feel it’s only fair to tell you your books have enriched my life and helped me see God and my fellow man in a new light. Your writing is a joy and a wonder. That’s the good news, from both our perspectives, I reckon.
The bad news–at least from my perspective–is your writing and your remarks on writing made me think about my own writing, and boy did that open a can of worms! (Not that it’s all your fault. I read Annie Dillard’s The Writing Life, too. Of course, most of the blame lay with me and my newly discovered inferiority complex.) Why? Well, I knew I could never write like you and she do, like you both say good writers do. I’m just not put together that way. I felt pretty awful about that for a while, even mooned around and moped some. Didn’t write a word, wasn’t sure I ever would again.
I guess that’s why the Lord stepped in the way He did. Nobody gives a pep talk like Him!
Basically, He had to remind me not everyone is created or destined to pen (or type) Pulitzer Prize-winning novels or thought-provoking, ageless essays that turn people inside out and leave them a little more awake and aware than they were when they opened the book to page one. Maybe the only thing we’re wired to write is a cracking good yarn. The catch? If yarn-writing is our vocation and our art, we have to take it as seriously–as sweat, blood, and tears seriously–as Shakespeare took writing The Tempest.
Besides, people like a good yarn, and maybe they need them, too, what with things being the way they are in the world today. Everybody needs a chance to kick back and relax now and then.
But the really great thing I realized, the mystery, the big joke is, even a light-weight yarn can be a means to an end and more than the sum of its parts. Something to do with the topsy-turvy wisdom of God and the kick He gets out of using the foolish things of the world to confound the wise and a sack lunch to feed the multitude. You know, I believe I’m learning to be good with that.
So, Fred, as it turns out, I have to thank you twice. Once for your books, each one a feast in itself, and once for the way you got me thinking and, yes, even doubting myself as a writer. I think I’m on solid ground now … or next door to it, anyway. Yes, I think I’ve finally gotten the message (so hopefully, I can stop blogging it out with myself): I’m okay, you’re okay. Actually, I’m okay, you’re amazing. But I’m okay with being okay, because there’s a lot more to this deal than just me and my sack lunch.
Thanks again, and have a terrific day.